How I test

Every product on this site gets used for weeks, usually months, before I write a word. Here's what that means for each category, so you can judge my reviews for yourself.

The ground rules

  • I buy most of what I test. If a brand sends me something for free, the review says so at the top.
  • No brand sees a review before it's published, and none of them can pay for a score.
  • Long-term updates. Reviews get revisited at 3, 6 and 12 months. If something breaks, you'll hear about it.
  • I tell you what I haven't tested. If I've never had a shoe in deep mud, I'll say so.

Walking pads

Each pad goes under a standing desk and gets used on normal workdays. I record:

  • Noise: decibel readings at 1 metre and from the room below, at 3 and 5 km/h, using a phone sound meter app. Phone meters aren't lab-grade, so treat these as comparisons between pads rather than absolute numbers.
  • Real speed vs the display: I chalk a mark on the belt, time 10 laps and work out the actual speed.
  • Footprint and height: measured with a tape. That tells you whether it slides under a couch or a bed.
  • Heat and smell: motor housing temperature after an hour of continuous walking.
  • Remote and app: whether they're actually useful, or just there.
  • Maintenance: how often the belt needs lubricating and re-centring, and how hard that is.

Trail and hiking shoes

I log kilometres, terrain and weather for every outing. I photograph the outsole at 50, 100 and 200 km so you can see the wear, and I score grip on wet rock, dry dirt and loose gravel separately.

Pizza ovens

I measure time to reach 400°C on the stone with an infrared thermometer, the hot and cold spots across the stone, fuel cost per pizza, and how long a cook takes once it's at heat. Then I cook a lot of pizza.

How scores work

Each product gets a score out of 10 for each thing that matters in its category, plus an overall score. The overall score is not an average. It's weighted towards what matters most for that kind of product. A walking pad that's quiet and reliable will beat one with a fancy app every time.

  • 9–10: outstanding. I'd buy it again tomorrow.
  • 7–8.9: good, with trade-offs worth knowing about.
  • 5–6.9: fine for some people. Read the "skip it if" line.
  • Under 5: I wouldn't buy it.